The new claim: Smith's exile as self-protection

On 17 November 2026, Michael Clarke told 2DayFM Breakfast that the psychological scars of Sandpapergate are a reason Steve Smith and his wife Dani have built a life in New York. I think a part of why Steve Smith lives in New York is because when he retired, he doesn't want to go to a pub, a guy gets drunk at the pub and yells something across the bar, Clarke said. He added that the families of the three sanctioned players — Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft — are not spoken about enough and that I can't imagine another country going as hard [at this scandal] as we have.

Clarke's intervention is striking because it reframes Smith's trans-Pacific lifestyle — often described in terms of business ventures and his wife's career — as a form of protective withdrawal. Smith, 37, played two Tests in South Africa last month before returning to New York and is expected to turn out for New South Wales in a Sheffield Shield match at the SCG starting 23 November, ahead of the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December.

Why the story reignited now

The immediate catalyst is Usman Khawaja's newly released biography, which alleges that the entire 2018 Australia team knew about the sandpaper plan. The claim has fractured the carefully maintained narrative that only Smith, Warner and Bancroft were aware. Pat Cummins, now Test captain, held a 70-minute press conference last week calling Khawaja's account 100% wrong and utter nonsense. David Warner responded by accusing Cricket Australia of a cover-up, suggesting bowlers Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon were never interviewed in the 2018 investigation. Former bowler Chadd Sayers, who was 12th man in the second Test at Gqeberha, backed Khawaja, saying he was handed sandpaper to remove from the field and that everyone in that side knew what was going on.

Competing testimonies and the credibility gap

The dispute now rests on mutually exclusive recollections. Cummins and the bowling group maintain they were unaware. Sayers, a peripheral figure in 2018, says a 60-to-90-minute team meeting after the Cape Town revelation discussed collective responsibility — a meeting Cummins says he does not recall. Warner's cover-up allegation targets the investigation's scope, not just player memory. Khawaja says he had an awkward conversation with Smith before publication; Smith has not spoken publicly since the allegations broke.

Mitchell Starc, asked about Bancroft's potential return to the public stage, offered a terse go for it and deflected questions about Sayers with you've got to ask Chadd that. Former coach Darren Lehmann called it a tough week for everyone involved and hoped the furore could be put to bed. Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg has ruled out reopening the investigation.

What Clarke's angle reveals about the scandal's half-life

Clarke, a World Cup-winning captain who knows the intensity of the Australian spotlight, is not merely gossiping. He is drawing a line from institutional failure — the 2018 investigation that sanctioned three men while the rest of the dressing room walked away — to private consequence. If Smith chooses New York over a Sydney pub, the scandal is not a closed chapter; it is a daily calculation. The fact that Clarke, Warner, Khawaja, Cummins, Sayers and now potentially Bancroft are all speaking, often at cross-purposes, suggests the truth of 2018 was never settled, only managed.

That management is now unravelling in real time. The next inflection points are concrete: Bancroft's manager says he is assessing whether he'll put something out in the coming days; Smith faces Australian media for the first time since the biography's release when he joins the NSW squad; the Perth Test on 9 December will be the first match since the allegations went public. None of these moments will resolve the factual dispute, but each will test whether Australian cricket can sustain a narrative that depends on silence.

Signal versus noise

Signal: A former captain asserting that the scandal's social cost drove a current great from his home country; a sitting captain and a former vice-captain publicly accusing each other of lying; a peripheral player corroborating the explosive claim in a best-selling book; the governing body refusing to reopen the file.

Noise: Speculation about Smith's exact motives for living in New York — business, family, lifestyle — which Clarke himself frames as a part of why, not the sole reason. The inevitable talkback cycles and social-media pile-ons that treat each press conference as a verdict.

What to watch next

  • Whether Cameron Bancroft releases a statement in the coming days, and whether it aligns with Khawaja or the bowlers.
  • Steve Smith's first public comments since the biography — likely at the SCG next week or in Perth on 9 December.
  • Whether Cricket Australia's refusal to reopen the investigation holds under mounting player testimony.
  • The Perth Test itself: team dynamics, body language, and any on-field fallout from a dressing room now publicly at war with its own history.